Goats have natural predators in Oklahoma that range from coyotes to mountain lions to packs of dogs. Horned goats can defend themselves against one coyote or dog to a certain extent, but have little chance against a pack of them. Cougars or mountain lions are impossible for any goat to deal with.
Livestock guardian dogs are one option to protect your goats. There are several breeds to available and mixed breeds do well. The best guardian dogs, "LGD's" are usually neutered. The mating season doesn't interfere with their work. However, there are intact LGDs that do an excellent job.
The dogs tend to develop primarily from a genetic tendency to guard livestock coupled with actual training from birth by working animals. Mother dogs can be seen with pups in the middle of the goat herd and often start training the pups at 8 - 12 weeks by taking them one at a time with the goats. Training by humans is almost impossible. The dogs either have the natural disposition or they don't. Training, to the extent it can be accomplished, comes from experienced dogs that communicate what should and should not be done.
A good LGD will sacrifice sleep, food, and the easy life in exchange for their own herd of goats to watch over. The good LGD's are worth every penny and are indispensable in larger ranches where it is difficult to monitor what may come over or under the fence. A protective LGD will fight off big cats, wolves, wild dogs, and coyotes, day or night. They work tirelessly 24/7 in scorching heat and bitter cold.
LGDs generally do not herd the goats. In fact, herding is a rarely seen trait. Some LGDs will occasionally try to lead or suggest a course of direction, but will yield to the herd leader and follow the goats wherever they roam. The dog's priority is protection, not herding.
These dogs bond with the goats and prefer living with them to people. We have seen one Anatolian female with pups also raise an orphan kid by nursing it with her pups. She raised the kid whose mother died a few days following its birth. We have a male Anatolian/Pyrenees cross that we had to teach not to carry around the kids. He was taking such good care of them that he wasn't letting them nurse. It was hilarious to see the does screeching and bellering for their babies as he carried them all over the pasture.
Finally with some gentle conversation and carefully taking them out of his mouth, he started leaving them alone. But let some negligent mother, like some we used to have, wander away from her kids and he will have them under his watchful care.
If you are going to raise goats, you need to give some careful attention to predators or they will eat up your profits!
Be sure to check out our directory of Livestock Guardian Dogs for sale.